All the pearls of drinking and dining wisdom can be found in this north side treasure chest

There aren’t a lot of bars that embody the tenets of hospitality as well as Gerald’s. That’s because there aren’t a lot of booze dons like its owners, Gerald Diffey and Mario Di Ienno. They are gents, scholars and rascals. They’re philosophers; ardent admirers of a good pork chop and a solid bar; and takers of very little shit. The pair have let their trusty crew take a stronger grip on the reins of late while they oversee things here and at their new restaurant, Brooks, but this Rathdowne Village wine bar remains a warm, woody champion of Motown, beautiful drinks, and service, service, service.

They let whoever first wanders into the bar of a night open bottles of whatever from the far-reaching and local-championing wine list, and those first three, say, Burgundies and rieslings become the by-the-glass selection.

Your wine typically comes with a recommendation, a back-story and if they like you, a practical joke. If, however, you prefer to be left in peace to mull over a chilled Chablis, they will unobtrusively and promptly fill your glass with the ghostly discretion of an Edwardian butler. As such, the bar is a sanctuary for industry professionals, writers and food fans.

Eats are simple. They’re scribbled daily on butchers paper on a ladder behind the bar. White anchovies; prosciutto cut into translucent sheets on a big, red, hand-cranked slicer; or maybe one of those pork chops cooked in cider. This is a bar that supports the community that religiously fills its seats, serving beers from local brewers Three Ravens alongside smashable Spanish Moritz lagers. In winter there are puffer jackets so you can sit outside. In summer there are gin and tonics ready before you’ve asked. That’s good bartending. That’s Gerald’s.

Who won the Melbourne pub awards?

First published on . Updated on .

By Gemima Cody   |  

Gerald's Bar details

386 Rathdowne St

Carlton North 3054

Telephone 03 9349 4748

Price per person including drinks $51 to $100

Open Daily 5-11pm

Carlton North area guide

Restaurants near Gerald's Bar

Skinner and Hackett

37m - What would you say if we told you there was a meat shop, where on Saturday...

Travelling Samovar Tea House

62m - This Carlton North tea house offers exotic and unsual teas from abroad...

Depot de Pain: Carlton

81m - This French bakery and café will sort out your mornings with crepes, coffee...

Bars & pubs near Gerald's Bar

The Brandon Hotel

429m - The Brandon Hotel, on a dimly lit, residential corner in Carlton North,...

The Dan O'Connell Hotel

532m - Complete with beer garden and tables out the front for the smoking and...

North Fitzroy Star

596m - The North Fitzroy Star is a cosy old English style pub, with hidden nooks,...

Other venues near Gerald's Bar

The Lab Perfumery

196m - Rathdowne Street is known for its cute cafés, more 'grown-up' boutiques and...

French Bikini

319m - Australians began to enjoy the exquisite collections from French Bikini when...


492m - Highly influential over the past 20 years, Dancehouse is a leading space...

Readers' comments, reviews, hints and pictures

Community guidelines

blog comments powered by Disqus

© 2007 - 2014 Time Out Group Ltd. All rights reserved. All material on this site is © Time Out.