Time Out Melbourne

The Everleigh offers an intimate, polished experience, from go to whoa

It hasn’t exactly been a quiet year for the Everleigh crew. Michael Madrusan and his crack team have had a raft of side-projects on the go, from the Navy Strength Ice Co to bespoke beers, bottled cocktails and the attention-grabbing launch of Heartbreaker in the city (our pick for 2016’s Best Party Bar). But for first-time visitors and regulars alike, the experience at the Everleigh is as seamless, polished and sophisticated as ever. And that’s why we’ve named it Best Cocktail Bar.

Yes, folks: this singular vision takes some serious beating. From the moment snappily dressed staff greet you at the top of the stairs until they bid you farewell, you know you’re in good hands. It’s seated-service only at this graceful speakeasy, so let the guys guide you to an intimate timber booth or prime stool at the bar. From there, you’re offered a menu of classic, age-old cocktails, craft beers, single malts, and a tight list of ten wines, including French Chablis, Italian sangiovese and Australian shiraz. Feel free to flip through the pages, but the real reason you’re here is for the Bartender’s Choice.

The Everleigh’s signature move invites you to tell the waiter what you’re craving, including the spirits you love and those you loathe, and while they’re standing at the table, they’ll come up with just the ticket. It’s like playing roulette with your round of drinks, except here, everybody wins. So Negroni-lovers might step slightly out of their comfort zone with a Cardinal of absinthe, vermouth and Campari. Old Fashioned fans may be served a Cocktail à la Louisiane, which marries rye whisky, Benedictine and Peychaud’s Bitters – a complex concoction that’s at once bold and smooth, sweet and savoury.

To help take the weight off multi-tasking Madrusan, Jakob Eztold has recently stepped in as bar manager. He was most recently at Italian heavyweight Rosetta, and was head bartender at Bar Americano, so the Everleigh’s consistency and unmatched quality looks to be in safe hands.

Updated on 9 Dec 2015.

By Sarah Gamboni   |   Photos by Gregory Lynch

The Everleigh details

Lvl 1
150-156 Gertrude St, Fitzroy 3065

Telephone 03 9416 2229

Nearby Stations: North Richmond; Collingwood

Price per person including drinks Up to $50

Open Daily 5.30pm-1am

The Everleigh website

The Everleigh map

Report a problem with this page

Restaurants and bars nearby

The Elk Room

Madrusan couldn’t build an ugly bar if he tried. Black drapes guard the...

Bar Clarine

13m - The softly spoken sister bar to rollicking neighbour Belle’s Hot Chicken...

Belle's Hot Chicken

13m - Southern-style fried chicken has nailed the eating zeitgeist, but the crew...

Gertrude Stein's

19m - If you, like us, have been celebrating everything about Belle's Hot Chicken...

More restaurants and bars nearby

Other venues nearby

Miss Gertrude

13m - Tucked below The Everleigh is the newest edition to the hippest...

Dagmar Rousset

30m - This store was made for those that delve in quirky delights and treat...

Megan Park: Fitzroy

32m - Melbourne designer Megan Park has just opened her second stand-alone...

More venues nearby
Petit Piknic

Petit Piknic

Melbourne's got the most fun, family-friendly Sunday session at Piknic Electronik

Readers' comments, reviews, hints and pictures

Community guidelines

blog comments powered by Disqus

Get the Time Out weekend planner. Straight to your inbox, every Thursday.
Read more