Time Out Melbourne

After a mere nine-months as Virginia Plain, this Flinders Lane restaurant has been reinvented as Mercy Bar

Yep, the rumours are true. After nine months of trading as Virginia Plain, Marco Santucci's cavernous Flinders Lane restaurant has had a do-over.

Saturday (June 15) was the restaurant's last day as the natural wine and fancy snack-loving Virginia. Now it's Mercy Bar and Eatery – a far more casual operation where the focus is more on beers and casual mod-European comfort food. 

Some things haven't changed – head chef Andy Harmer is still bashing the pans, and they're still spinning vinyl behind the long marble bar. But you can expect to find the wine list more concise and the space a little less corporate. 

"The changes aren't huge," front man Mat Beyer tells us, "but they will make a big difference. We always wanted Virginia to be a more casual and now we've finally decided to go for it."

The dining room's round tables have been recycled as stools and a whole lot of communal tables and new artwork thrown in.

Stay tuned for a new review.

Virginia Plain is Marco Santucci’s new semi-formal bistro meticulously ticking all the boxes – mod-European share plates, waistcoated staff playing vinyl records; they’ve even got ex-MasterChef contestant Mat Beyer running front of house and doing social media.

In a word, it’s big. Not just in size – although, unimpeded by any partition, the mammoth slate-toned Finders Lane cavern seems to run the length of a city block. With those high ceilings and 25 seat granite bar it’s pretty grandiose – something you’ll enjoy if you’re sick of eating at places where you have to sit on someone else’s lap, although it can feel like you’re the only person who RSVPd to the party, even on a Saturday.

There are big names too – executive chef Andy Harmer (ex-Vue De Monde) is overseeing the highly technique-driven menu where even the spring vegetables are subjected to a bacon foam facelift, while Raúl Moreno Yagüe (also ex-Vue, and SOS) is filling your wine glass. Nobody does it like this guy. The charismatic Spaniard flourishes those bottles with the flare of a magician-cum-matador. He’ll push some upper end gear, perhaps a Croatian Malvazija varietal treated on cedar so it has a warm smoky edge, but more because it’s delicious, not because it’s expensive.

There are a lot of things we enjoy about drinking in this restaurant. House pinot noir on tap; non-sparkling super dry ciders that are more like wine, and decent cocktails – go a La Rosita of tequila, Campari and vermouth served straight up and guaranteed to take you from struggle street back to party central in two sips.

Food wise, the rule of thumb here is keep it simple. Start with some fat Batemans Bay oysters or aged jamón (air dried Spanish ham – extra salty and extra piggy) over the foie gras and quince croquettes. The indistinguishable breaded and deep fried balls of creamy foie gras are intense, while those filled with the fruit paste are plain odd. It’s Russian roulette.

We’re right behind a marriage of sweet seared scallops and a nutty black pudding, cooked in a deboned pig’s trotter, sliced and fanned across buttery mash. Oof. Vegetarians should get the artichoke salad, a tangle of shaved raw heart and baby greens enriched with a buttery cep mushroom purée.

Skip the salty seafood stew for lamb three ways – fatty, soft slow roasted shoulder, breaded sweetbreads (those tasty, spongey thymus glands - a little overcooked in this case) and a neatly trimmed cutlet turned into an ugly-delicious meat paddle-pop with translucent stomach lining enveloping a basil mousse, binding it to the meat. The smoky eggplant dip and dehydrated crisps do more for the dish’s looks than taste.

We wish the milk ice cream and coconut-lime sorbet were desserts in their own right – we're less keen on the cakey chocolate fondant and eggy coconut souffle they're supporting.

The ideas here are big, ballsy and ambitious, and for us, not all the dishes are quite there yet. Hopefully, time and tweaks will bring things together. Until then, stick to snacks or go the great value four-course tasting menu for $55 and spend your spare pennies on their excellent booze.

Updated on 7 Apr 2014.

By Gemima Cody   |   Photos by Graham Denholm

Mercy Bar and Eatery details

31 Flinders Ln, Melbourne 3000

Telephone 03 9290 0400

Open Mon-Wed 11am-11pm; Thu-Sat 11am-1am

Mercy Bar and Eatery website

Mercy Bar and Eatery map

Report a problem with this page

Restaurants and bars nearby

Cumulus Up

31m - So Andrew McConnell has opened a wine bar, and it’s amazing. Which will...

Tom Thumb

54m - Tom Thumb is the brand new hole-in-the-wall espresso bar uniting the...


74m - Located on the ground floor of Hotel Lindrum, Felt (n amed after the green...

More restaurants and bars nearby

Other venues nearby

Emily Green

Both Emily Green’s jewellery and artwork is bursting with colour, from in...

Craft Victoria

Craft Victoria celebrates Australian craft and design at state, national and...

Arc One Gallery

31m - Situated in Melbourne's arty Flinders Lane, Arc One exhibits Australian and...

Hotel Lindrum

74m - Its Art Deco neon sign has lit up the city’s skyline for years, but...

More venues nearby
Petit Piknic

Petit Piknic

Melbourne's got the most fun, family-friendly Sunday session at Piknic Electronik

Readers' comments, reviews, hints and pictures

Community guidelines

blog comments powered by Disqus

Get the Time Out weekend planner. Straight to your inbox, every Thursday.
Read more