Time Out Melbourne

Three years? Has it really been three years? That’s the restaurant equivalent of middle age, but the Carlton Wine Room is doing nicely, thanks very much

Sometimes only time can afford a proper perspective on a restaurant. When it’s had time to settle into its polished timber floorboards, its handsome window arches, it can finally figure out what it wants to be when it grows up.  

Carlton Wine Room was a bit of an attention-seeker when it first introduced the ’burb to its taxidermied pigeons. It was one big trend alert with a flexible - some would say confusing - menu, some adventurous food and a helluva drinks focus.

These days things are pared back. There’s a bit less adventure, but also a bit less risk. CWR feels like it could have been here for 20 years instead of three. It feels lived-in, loved and calmly convincing.

Co-owner and manager Jay Bessell remains the human focal point, still resplendent in a cravat and the kind of enthusiasm for the still-lengthy, still-beautiful, utterly quaffable Italian-leaning wine list - his list – that could power the city grid.

After a change of chef, the food is the main point of departure, with a simpler selection of entrees and mains (who would have thought?) How totally old-school. It’s all still easily share-able – just ask Jay - and there’s a great list of bar snacks, including oysters - feet off, horseradish on - rillettes, and soft shell crab on herb aioli.

The food is confidently, unpretentiously, as Euro 101 as you’re likely to encounter. There’s steak tartare, a mighty puck that could do with a bit more piquancy and a bit more duck egg yolk but has a good bit of beefy heft in the rough-chopped meat. Fried zucchini flowers oozing smoked goats’ cheese, with asparagus and curls of pecorino, make a good argument early summer eating.

Scallops team up with their old buddy blood pudding – sorry, morcilla – with little nubs of fried caper, and there’s pork that despite being sous vided still has best-in-show crackle, all salt and toffeed crunch. The apple puree it’s sitting with catapults it into Christmas dinner territory; the apple and herb salad with a hint of ginger gives it something more. To finish – wagyu rump cap (nine-score, beef nerds), blushing pink in a dark maroon sea of textbook red wine jus so glossy you could check your teeth for parsley in it.

Bravo. These days, the Carlton Wine Room along with the Town Mouse and D.O.C. have triangulated a little Carlton corner of cool. Bring it on for the next three years.

Updated on 30 Jan 2015.

By Larissa Dubecki   |   Photos by Graham Denholm

The Carlton Wine Room details

172-174 Faraday St, Carlton 3053

Telephone 03 9347 2626

Price per person including drinks Up to $50

Open Mon-Wed 5pm-late; Thu-Sat noon-late

The Carlton Wine Room website

Book now

The Carlton Wine Room map

Report a problem with this page

Restaurants and bars nearby

The Town Mouse

35m - If you've been waiting with bated breathe to see what would become of the...

Yo-Chi Carlton

68m - This self-serve frozen yogurt joint takes variation to a whole new level. As...

More restaurants and bars nearby

Other venues nearby

Museo Italiano

73m - Museo Italiano is a partnership between the Italian Historical Society and...

La Mama Theatre

107m - Inspired by the 1960s New York performing arts scene and located in an old...

La Mama Courthouse

107m - Head on through the back of the Lygon Street Safeway supermarket complex and...

More venues nearby


Got an itch for short films? Flickerfest is here to scratch it

Readers' comments, reviews, hints and pictures

Community guidelines

blog comments powered by Disqus

Get the Time Out weekend planner. Straight to your inbox, every Thursday.
Read more