Michael James Manaia

10 Oct 2012-28 Oct 2012,


Melbourne Festival,


Theatre Reviews

Critics' choice

A powerful one-man show offering an emotional glimpse into the heart of alienation

This event has finished

Dunedin-based playwright John Broughton spent 17 years in the New Zealand Territorial Army, and has written a number of works for theatre that deal with the psychological effects of war on returned soldiers. His close familiarity with the material evident throughout this one-man play. There is a roughness in the writing that sounds like intimacy, and a passion and directness in the argument that manifests as a real sense of distress for his central character.

There is also a lingering sort of electricity in the work, which, when it was first performed in 1991, was part of a wave of important Maori plays redefining New Zealand's theatre. It still has an impressive, youthful forcefulness about it. A sense of bravado. Yes, occasionally, stylistically, the text feels a little dated, but in the hands of a vigorous showman like Te Kohe Tuhaka much of that original energy seems revived.

The story is framed as a monodrama, narrated by the explosive and charismatic Michael James Manaia.

Manaia's father fought in World War Two as part of a Maori Battalion, even fighting at the Battle of Monte Cassino. Service in the First and Second World Wars was long seen as a point of pride for the Maori community, and still is. Broughton, however, questions whether this sense of pride, a specifically masculine pride, perhaps led to an obscuring of the long-term psychological effects of war.

Michael's father, for instance, returns from the war a stern, unapproachable man with a violent temper. Though he appears able to adjust socially, working as a teacher, he takes his repressed frustrations out on his sons.

The effect of war on Michael, however, is even more devastating. Following in his father's footsteps, he volunteers for service in Vietnam. The way in which Broughton shows us faint hints of the invisible hand – the darkly angelic hand – that draws Michael inevitably into combat is a real highpoint of the writing.

On returning to Aotearoa, having seen "everything", plagued by terrible dreams, apparently manic, tending toward the delusional, unquestionably suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder, Michael also has to contend with the effects of Agent Orange on his health. The combination leads to a brutal, nightmarish finale.

Tuhaka brings extraordinary intensity as Michael, catapulting himself across the stage, ducking and weaving, harshly wrenching his mood one way then the other. In one breath he might go from softly crooning Bette Midler to weeping for his dead brother to screaming curses at his father, all while retaining a surprising sense of the comic.

A simple set of two roughly planked platforms by Daniel Williams wonderfully brings out the savagery and solitude in Michael's character, and Nathanial Lees direction keeps Tuhaka prowling and pouncing at a fierce pace.

This is potent theatre, which, though occasionally showing its age and raw origins, stills feels immediate and confronting in its arguement and energy.

Presented by New Zealand's national Maori theatre company Taki Rua and fortyfive downstairs as part of the Melbourne Festival.

Sign up to our monthly arts newsletter

First published on . Updated on .

By Andrew Fuhrmann   |   Photos by Philip Merry   |  

Michael James Manaia details


45 Flinders Ln

Melbourne 3000

Nearby Stations: Flinders St

Telephone 136 100

Price from $25.00 to $45.00

Date 10 Oct 2012-28 Oct 2012

Open Tue-Fri 7.30pm; Sat 4pm & 8pm; Sun 5pm

Director: Nathaniel Lees

Cast: Te Kohe Tuhaka

fortyfivedownstairs details

Melbourne area guide

fortyfivedownstairs map

Restaurants near fortyfivedownstairs

Cumulus Inc

0m - Andrew McConnell once did work experience in a hair salon. He asked us not...

Tom Thumb

65m - Tom Thumb is the brand new hole-in-the-wall espresso bar uniting the...

Cecconi's Cantina

70m - Cecconi's Cantina is divided into two separate dining areas to perfectly...

Bars & pubs near fortyfivedownstairs

Cumulus Up

87m - So Andrew McConnell has opened a wine bar, and it’s amazing. Which will...


103m - They pull out all the stops – and the liquid nitrogen – here. At any...

Arthurs Bar Lounge

116m - It might be the red velvet pillars that give it away or the curved glass...

Other venues near fortyfivedownstairs

Barre Body

11m - What’s good for Madonna, Zooey Deschanel and Natalie Portman is sure as...


79m - The best bookstore for architecture, urban design and landscape books.

Arc One Gallery

87m - Situated in Melbourne's arty Flinders Lane, Arc One exhibits Australian and...

Readers' comments, reviews, hints and pictures

Community guidelines

blog comments powered by Disqus

© 2007 - 2014 Time Out Group Ltd. All rights reserved. All material on this site is © Time Out.