Time Out Melbourne

An engrossing doc goes behind-the-scenes at a newsprint institution

The Gray Lady lifts her skirt for all to see, with mixed results, in Andrew Rossi’s year-in-the-life documentary. Granted unprecedented access to the Times’ media desk, the director, acting as a one-man crew, followed the day-to-day operations of this equally venerated and scorned institution – now even more beleaguered in the age of New Media.

It’s engrossing viewing in the moment. We get to see many of the paper’s stories (WikiLeaks; the Tribune Company mismanagement) from inception to completion, and Rossi fascinatingly compares and contrasts the reporters’ methods: Tech-savvy journo Brian Stelter is perpetually plugged-in – he’s on the WikiLeaks Iraq War footage (“Collateral Murder”) while its YouTube hits are still in the low digits. His seeming opposite is the great David Carr, a weathered scribe with quick instincts – we watch him pungently dress down an editor at Vice during one tense news-gathering session – but a slow-burn approach. “I still can’t get over the feeling that Brian Stelter was a robot assembled in the Times basement to destroy me,” he quips of his Facebook- and Twitter-promoting friend. Half jest? Half requiem?

There’s a strong sense during much of the doc that the Times’ future is bleak. At one point, then-executive editor Bill Keller offers a sobering appraisal of the paper’s many failures, invoking names like Blair and Miller with how-could-we wistfulness, while squirming about upcoming layoffs. You wish Rossi could have maintained this stiff-drink ambivalence throughout. But the film is too often presumptively pie-eyed about the Times’ bastion-of-reportage rep (this is especially evident whenever the perspective shifts away from Carr, whose world-weariness perfectly counterbalances the film’s tendency to casually lionise the fourth estate). And the falsely euphoric close is a big misstep – Pulitzers, it would seem, are the ultimate Band-Aid. What was that old adage about printing the legend?

Madman, DVD RRP $29.95

David Carr on Page One: Inside the New York Times

Updated on 3 Mar 2014.

By Keith Uhlich   |  

Page One: Inside the New York Times review video

Petit Piknic

Petit Piknic

Melbourne's got the most fun, family-friendly Sunday session at Piknic Electronik

Readers' comments, reviews, hints and pictures

Community guidelines

blog comments powered by Disqus

Get the Time Out weekend planner. Straight to your inbox, every Thursday.
Read more