Time Out Sydney

The popular South American joint rises from the ashes  

Porteño is awesome. Always has been, really, since the day it opened those cast iron gates to hungry customers in 2010. Back then, queues crowded the courtyard and snaked down Cleveland Street. People wrestled to get in for a fix of Argentinean-style, eight-hour wood-fired pig and those Brussels sprouts. Rockabilly chefs/owners Ben Milgate, Elvis Abrahanowicz and maître d’ Sarah Doyle shot to fame overnight, appearing on MasterChef and fronting magazines everywhere. It was Porteño mania, and we were there, chairing the fan base.

Things came to an abrupt halt in January this year, when a fire hit the kitchen and caused extensive damage. The guys quickly opened temporary restaurant Popteño in Rushcutters Bay, during the dry-out. Now Porteño is back – with a newly revised menu. The king has returned to Cleveland Street.

Some old favourites remain, and the pâté is still the best way to start. It's undercharged at $3 per person, and testament to how much these guys want you to have a good time. Your bread roll arrives with a little dish of punchy, house-made pâté and a bowl of olive oil and chimichurri to freshen things up.

Now that your appetite is whetted, order some wine. Co-owner and sommelier Joe Valore has curated the South American-centric list, one of the finest in town. Go with red – it pairs better with this sort of food, and it feels wrong to have anything else in the white, cloistered, high-ceilinged setting. The Tahuan Bonarda from Argentina is available by the glass or bottle. It’s spicy with dark fruits and soft tannins, and goes with just about anything.

The must-order starter is the vitello tonnato. Reminiscent of a remixed steak tartare, it is simultaneously rich, creamy, salty, sour and smoky. Thinly sliced cured beef is topped with big chunks of gently smoked Spanish mackerel, salty capers, soft-yolk quail eggs and anchovy mayo. Little half moons of lemon lift things to extraordinary heights. A near-perfect dish.

Another new addition: tables of two no longer have to choose between the eight-hour pig or eight-hour lamb. They’ll do a mixed bowl featuring both. You see the beasts roasting over the fire pit as you walk in; it’s what you came for, so you might as well order it. Both meats are unfathomably juicy, and you get cuts from all bits of the animal along with loads of crackling.

There are, of course, plenty of other meat options. The Kobe wagyu beef skirt steak is sliced into big, fat marbled strips and cooked medium, leaving the texture buttery within and charred on the outside. It’s savoury, caramel-like and worth every bite. Don’t look past the morcilla blood sausage, either. Soft and barely spiced, it pairs beautifully with the sweet, grassy notes of the roasted red capsicum it crowns. As for sides, the Brussels sprouts remain a must. But don’t ignore the crunchy grilled broccolini with creamy, sherry-rich walnut sauce and crisp onions. Want more fat? Order the braised wintergreens with Provolone béchamel. A bowl on a cold evening will set you right.

Dessert was never really the thing here, but the chocolate “Bahibe” is changing that. It’s a brownie topped with dehydrated chocolate mousse (sort of like an Aero) with smooth chocolate cream, pear sorbet and fresh passionfruit poured on top. It’s a textural delight, and a nice way to end if you still have room to fit it in.

There’s plenty to love about Porteño. It was, and remains, bloody excellent in every possible way: the food, the wine, the beautiful interior and the warm, knowledgeable service. In 2013 they released Recipes for a Good Time, a cookbook whose title couldn’t be more fitting. We dare you not to have one the minute you walk through those gates. 

Sign up to our monthly Food and Drink newsletter

First published on . Updated on .

By Freya Herring   |   Photos by Anna Kucera

Porteño details

Address
358 Cleveland St, Surry Hills 2010

Telephone 02 8399 1440

Price per person including drinks $51 to $100

Open Tue-Sat 6pm-late

Porteño website

Porteño map

Report a problem with this page

Restaurants and bars nearby

Gardel's Bar

10m - Absence makes the heart grow fonder, and in the three months that...

Dr Faustus

60m - Dr Faustus sold his soul to the devil for power and knowledge. On a...

Nourishing Quarter

80m - What  Gluten is the protein found in wheat and alternative grains...

Twig Cafe

89m - Twig is a lovely little cafe tucked in behind Garden Life on Cleveland...

More restaurants and bars nearby

Other venues nearby

Garden Life

89m - Garden Life can help you create a little slice of rainforest or a...

Dolly Up

101m - Dolly Up specialises in vintage bridalwear and designer dresses for special...

More venues nearby
Best yum cha in Sydney

Best yum cha in Sydney

Fluffy pork buns. Silky, thin tofu skin. Beef tendon. The sweetest prawn dumplings. We've eaten 'em and now you will too

Readers' comments, reviews, hints and pictures

Community guidelines

blog comments powered by Disqus