Time Out Sydney

First it was a church. Then it was a library. Now it’s a buzzy Italian restaurant


Cronulla has grown up behind our backs! Owner Mario Kalpou has main-lined a fresh dose of style into the area with his new modern-Italian venture, the Old Library. And chefs David Magill and Danny Russo, previously from Italian Kitchen and Bar in Bondi Junction, are plating up classic Italian flavours combined with contemporary technique.
Take the beguiling caprese marshmallows: a herb broth is whipped with gelatine, set into fluffy squares, then rolled in a soft parmesan crumb that vanishes as it hits your tongue, leaving a mouthful of flavour in its wake.
Roman-style zucchini flowers are stuffed with a porcini and ricotta mix and come crisp and hot. There’s a little Middle Eastern influence in the lamb shoulder, which is slow-braised, shredded, pressed then pan-fried to create a crisp crust, and is served on top of roasted eggplant (which would have been a win if it had been a purée), hazelnuts and pomegranate seeds. Can’t decide what to order? There are five different ‘social plates’ ranging from seafood, to antipasti and cheese.
The atmosphere here slinks between a fitting setting for a summery long lunch that stretches into afternoon cocktails, to a dressed-up evening spot for dinner. And the cocktails here are really kicking arse, too. The Whisky Business is a short dose of smoky toffee combining whiskey, ginger liqueur, house-made spice syrup and fresh lemon, finished with caramelised Lagavulin. The Chapter III will also impress, with Campari, Punt e Mes, Pimms, rosé, grapefruit juice, lime, mint and Fever Tree ginger ale.
While the the pastas are a rather pricey hit-or-miss, the custard apple panna cotta is a sublime tropical wobble with a crunchy hazelnut praline and a chewy rhubarb roll-up (just like at school!) impaled in its centre – a dish that you ain’t going to want to share.

The Old Library has stepped up the Cronulla dining scene, could this be a taste of more to come down south? 

Want more restaurant reviews and food events? Sign up to our monthly Food & Drink newsletter

Updated on 19 Nov 2012.

By Sophie McComas   |  

The Old Library details

Shop 1/15 Surf Road, Cronulla 2230

Telephone 02 9544 5360

Price per person including drinks $10.00 to $100.00

Open Thu-Sun noon-late

The Old Library website

The Old Library map

Report a problem with this page

Restaurants and bars nearby

Grind Espresso

Just up from Cronulla Beach , the much beloved Grind cafe has moved from...

The Brass Monkey

99m - If you’re in the mood for live music any night of the week, the Brass...

Fratelli Del Mare

145m - Fratelli Del Mare is an Italian restaurant with a modern Australian twist....

South Beach Seafoods

152m - Before the sun sets, grab a box of fish and chips from South Beach Seafoods...

More restaurants and bars nearby

Other venues nearby

Around Cronulla

130m - This beachside suburb is located 26km south of Sydney . Its vast stretch of...

Cronulla Beach

1660m - Cronulla Beach is fully patrolled beach with one of the strongest surf...

More venues nearby
Collaboration Brew launch

Collaboration Brew launch

Bottled Lightning Co are back in the Inner West, and getting ready to tap their latest collaboration brew at Public House Petersham

Readers' comments, reviews, hints and pictures

Community guidelines

blog comments powered by Disqus

Get the Time Out weekend planner. Straight to your inbox, every Thursday.
Read more