Time Out Sydney

Head to this Hellenic restaurant above the Newtown Hotel for a share-plate extravaganza 

Speakeasy-style Greek restaurants are a bit of a Sydney specialty. Newtown’s Steki Taverna is hidden behind an old door, lit by a single flickering light. The only way you’d know it was there is the sound of duelling bouzoukis filtering though onto the street. In Marrickville, the Corinthian is little more than a shopfront with a restaurant out back where you can order a whole braised sheep’s head. In the CBD, Diethnes is one of Sydney’s oldest Greek restaurants and a riot of basement-level awesome kitschiness. 

And now here’s the Animal, hidden (sort of) on the second level of the Newtown Hotel offering surprisingly decent food and wine on tap. Yes, wine on tap. If you're of the opinion tap pours of Marlborough sauvignon blanc are a sign of the coming apocalypse, give a Hitachino red rice ale a tilt instead.  
While the downstairs pub has been given a spit’n’polish – insert festoon lighting, shiny pinnies, decorative drag-queen-and-leopard-print pool tables – upstairs has been given a full reboot. The balcony is hot property. By day it’s a great place to drink a cold beer and catch a breeze. By evening, watch the sunset over Newtown’s crumbling terraces. Thing is, everyone has the same idea – there’s actually a line up for it through the restaurant. Not ideal if you’re trying to eat, as there’s a strong chance you’ll be covered in at least half a beer by the end of the meal, just by merit of sitting close to the door.
The big, placemat-style menu is packed with dishes made to share. Start with some creamy haloumi – low on the squeak so you can slam it down fast – scattered with mint and served with a cheek of lemon. Split-pea dip involves more of a dragging than dipping motion, but it’s good all the same with spongy triangles of grilled pita bread.
Give the skewered beef tri-tip a miss (sadly for us, it’s overcooked and pretty chewy) in favour of the wood-roasted suckling lamb. It comes out in a massive bowl – perfect for sharing family-style – all tender, thick slices freshened up with a squeeze of lemon. Fork at will.
Veggos can get down with a flaky, light spinach, ricotta and fetta pie. Or maybe just a big Greek salad crowned with a thick slice of crumbly, firm fetta. We also dig the salad of watermelon chunks, fetta, mint and shards of deep-fried pita bread, though admittedly we leave it to the end as a palate-cleanser.
Eating at the Animal has its merits – really friendly staff and some damn decent Greek food. Your good-times-o-metre will ping one way or the other depending on your threshold for being elbowed in the back by punters jostling for balcony time, and how many Cooper’s you can stand wearing at the end of one dinner. Yasou. 

Want more restaurant reviews and food events? Sign up to our monthly Food & Drink newsletter

Updated on 14 Oct 2015.

By Myffy Rigby   |   Photos by Caroline McCredie

The Animal details

174 King Street , Newtown 2042

Telephone 02 9557 6399

Price per person including drinks $10.00 to $100.00

Open Daily noon-midnight

The Animal website

Book now

The Animal map

Report a problem with this page

Restaurants and bars nearby

Newtown Hotel

There’s nothing now to suggest that this was one of Sydney’s most...

Guzman y Gomez

14m - It may look like little more than a fast food joint, but it ain't so. Their...


36m - Newtown’s dining scene is taking a turn for the better, starting with this...

More restaurants and bars nearby

Other venues nearby


15m - Beautifully presented fruit tisanes, exotic flavour combinations, eccentric...

CK Gallery

82m - This commercial gallery was opened by Jason Williams and Carolyn Kerr in...

Tokyo Sing Song

114m - Super offbeat entertainment is the order of the day at this late-night...

Pretty Dog

146m - Tanya Stevanovic has set up shop in a beautiful old terrace that does...

More venues nearby

Readers' comments, reviews, hints and pictures

Community guidelines

blog comments powered by Disqus

Get the Time Out weekend planner. Straight to your inbox, every Thursday.
Read more