Time Out Sydney

Looking for a good argument to eat in a hotel lobby? Let chef Mark Best and Pei Modern convince you

We’d better start off by letting you know that this is not Marque Lite. The only thing this new mod-city bistro has in common with the Surry Hills prog-stralian fine diner is restaurateur and executive chef, Mark Best. What you will find, though, is the same commitment to quality and independent ideas when it comes to plating and flavours. 

This isn’t his first Pei rodeo. Best opened a Melbourne version a few years back to rave reviews. Back on Sydney soil (aaaah) and chef Matt Germanchis is running the show day to day, serving croquettes that are almost rosti-like with their big shreds of potato interlaced with generous amounts of salt cod. Crisp toasts are piled with hand chopped of raw beef interspersed with (so many!) capers and dressed with horseradish cream. And just to up the luxe factor, slivers of urchin loll over the top, making for a creamy, hot, fatty and cooling two bite snack.

On top of elegance and originality on the plate, there’s also a real focus on basic comfort here. Roast chickens are chained and hang over the fire like tasty S&M rotisserie. And of course, there’s the signature hearty delight of gibblety casarecce – firm pasta shapes, like half-cut stubby straws, chicken meatballs and meat bits, all doused in plenty of melted butter and a little cheese. Winter’s gone, summer’s arrived and we’re still ordering it. 

Some things don’t quite rock us quite the same way. The lamb saganaki burger is a salty number, and despite those deliciously crisp puffy onion rings and the krautish relish, we still wouldn’t go back for it. The blueberries and confit lemon splodges with what is otherwise a really good pork cutlet don’t quite get us dancing on the tables, either. But boy, that sucker is juicy. (PS: if you're used to a well-done pork cutlet, think again – these guys serve theirs fearlessly pink). Add a salad of beets and figs with a hale of mustard seeds for some pared back brightness.

It’s a big menu, and one that could see you coming in for a glass of wine with a round of parmesan shortbread and anchovies – they’re like the best ever savoury version of a melting moment – as easily as the musky Rangers Valley hanger steak with all the trimmings. Whatever happens, you’d be fools to skip over the sweet stuff. There’s fresh, juicy tamarillo with a big scoop of house-made vanilla ice cream resting on an almost buttery clotted cream. Duck egg sauternes custard, an ode to that special Marque pre-dessert, is as bittersweet and silky as its sister. The chocolate tart with eucalyptus caramel, though delicious, is a deconstructed "tart" and fairly annoying to eat. As with all things, we defer to Meatloaf: "two out of three aint bad." 

There’s plenty to like here thanks to the mad skills on the floor and in the kitchen. Just imagine if we could get a Pei Modern in Marrickville, Redfern or a side street in Glebe. We'll make you a mood board, Mark.

Want more restaurant reviews and food events? Sign up to our monthly Food & Drink newsletter

Updated on 14 Jan 2015.

By Myffy Rigby   |   Photos by Anna Kucera

Pei Modern details

Four Seasons Hotel
199 George St, Sydney 2000

Telephone 02 9250 3160

Price per person including drinks $51 to $100

Open Mon-Fri noon-3pm, 5.30pm-late; Sat 5.30pm-late

Pei Modern website

Book now

Pei Modern map

Report a problem with this page

Restaurants and bars nearby

Grain Bar

36m - Discover this sleek bar jutting off to the side of the Four Seasons Hotel....

Wine Odyssey

69m - Sure, the Wine Odyssey will never be mistaken for Sydney’s latest bar du...

Jacksons on George

78m - This George Street stalwart has five bars over four floors, now...


81m - The menu changes pretty regularly, depending on the season but signatures...

More restaurants and bars nearby

Other venues nearby

Aeon Spa

Found on level three at the Four Seasons Hotel , Aeon Spa features six...

Four Seasons Hotel

86m - The former Regent Hotel (some taxi drivers still know it by that name) was...

Shangri-La Hotel

144m - The Shangri-La is synonymous with some of the best views in Sydney, seeing...

Science House

144m - Science House in The Rocks received the first Sulman Award of the Royal...

More venues nearby
Collaboration Brew launch

Collaboration Brew launch

Bottled Lightning Co are back in the Inner West, and getting ready to tap their latest collaboration brew at Public House Petersham

Readers' comments, reviews, hints and pictures

Community guidelines

blog comments powered by Disqus

Get the Time Out weekend planner. Straight to your inbox, every Thursday.
Read more